Walk down any road of newer houses in Telford or on the Shrewsbury estates the winter after a big storm and you will see the same thing on half the back boundaries: lap panels flat in the garden, or gone altogether, with the concrete posts standing there on their own. Two streets over, on the older houses with closeboard, the fences are still up. That is the whole comparison in one picture, but it is worth understanding why, because panels are not always the wrong answer and closeboard is not always worth the extra.
We have been building both across Shropshire since 1997. This is an honest side-by-side: how each is made, which one survives an exposed plot, why the post choice is really a gravel board choice, what the repair bill looks like after a storm, and where the cost gap sits.
How Each Is Built
Closeboard: board by board, on site
A closeboard fence arrives as a pile of timber, not a stack of panels. Posts go in first. Horizontal arris rails — triangular-section timbers — are fixed between the posts, usually three for a six-foot fence. A gravel board runs along the bottom to keep the boards out of the wet. Then the feather edge boards, each one tapered across its width, are nailed to the rails one at a time, each overlapping the last by an inch or so. A capping rail along the top, with a counter rail beneath it, finishes it and sheds rain off the end grain.
Because it is built in place, closeboard follows the ground. It goes round gentle curves, rakes down a slope without stepping, and copes with a boundary that is not quite straight or not quite level, which describes most Shropshire gardens.
Lap panels: factory-made, dropped in
A lap panel — overlap, waney edge, the names vary — is a finished unit from a factory: thin horizontal boards overlapped and stapled into a frame, usually 6ft wide. Posts go in at panel-width centres, and the panels drop into slots in concrete posts or are nailed to timber ones. It is quick. A competent team can fit a lot of panel fence in a day, which is where the price advantage comes from.
The panel is only as strong as the frame and the staples holding the boards to it, and the whole thing is one rigid unit. It cannot follow the ground; on a slope it has to be stepped, and each step is a gap at the bottom or a triangle of daylight at the top.
Exposed Sites vs Sheltered Gardens
This is where the two fences part company, and it is the question we ask first on any survey: how much wind does this boundary take?
Shropshire has plenty of exposed ground. Anything on the slopes of the Long Mynd or in the Shropshire Hills, the villages along Wenlock Edge, the high ground around the Wrekin, and open plots on the edge of villages out towards the south, Clun and the Welsh border all take wind that a town garden never sees. A six-foot solid fence is, in effect, a sail. In a gale a lap panel flexes, the staples let go of the boards or the frame lifts out of its slot, and the panel goes. Closeboard on the same boundary has every board nailed individually to rails that are fixed to the posts; there is no single unit to lift out, and the boards are heavier and stiffer. It flexes, it holds.
Sheltered gardens are a different story. A rear garden in the middle of Shrewsbury, walled or hedged on three sides, or a Telford estate plot with houses close on every side, does not see that wind. Panels there are fine. Plenty of the panel fences we fit in town are still standing years later, and we would not talk a customer out of them on a sheltered plot with a tight budget.
Concrete vs Timber Posts — and Why the Gravel Board Is the Real Decision
People spend a long time on posts. Concrete or timber? Concrete lasts effectively forever, never rots, and holds a fence rigid in wet ground. Timber looks better, particularly on a cottage or period boundary, costs less, and is easier to work with on an awkward run. Either can carry a closeboard fence or a panel fence.
But the post is not usually what kills a fence. The bottom of the boards is. Timber sitting in wet soil rots from the bottom up, and in a Shropshire winter the bottom six inches of an unprotected fence are wet from November to March. The fix is the gravel board: a concrete or treated timber board running along the ground under the fence, so the feather edge boards or the panel sit on it rather than in the mud. Fit it and the timber above it stays dry; skip it and the fence has a shelf life whatever the posts are made of.
So the decision we would actually push you on is not concrete versus timber posts — we will recommend concrete on anything exposed, wet or long, and timber where the look matters — it is gravel board or no gravel board. The answer is always gravel board. On concrete posts with concrete gravel boards, the timber never touches the ground at all, and that is the combination we recommend for most Shropshire rear boundaries.
Repairability: A Board vs a Panel
This is the argument for closeboard that most people have not thought about until the first repair.
When a closeboard fence takes damage — a branch comes down on it, a football goes through it, a gale lifts the capping — you replace what broke. Six boards, a rail, a length of capping. The damaged boards are prised off, new ones nailed on, and the rest of the fence is untouched. It is a couple of hours, not a day, and the new boards weather in alongside the old.
When a lap panel takes the same damage, the panel is finished. There is nothing to repair on a split or blown-out panel; it comes out whole and a new one goes in. Matching the silvered, weathered colour of the panels either side is luck. And if the panel went because the post slot let it go, the new one will go the same way in the next storm.
Over twenty years the repair bill is where the real cost difference lives. A closeboard fence that has had a few boards replaced after each bad winter is still the same fence. A panel fence that has lost a panel or two every couple of years is a patchwork.
Cost Per Metre — Where the Gap Is, and When Panels Are the Right Call
Panels are cheaper on the day. There is no argument about that. The material is cheaper, and a panel fence goes up faster than a closeboard fence because the labour has been done in a factory rather than in your garden. On a straightforward run in a sheltered garden, the difference between the two can be meaningful on the first quote.
The gap closes as soon as you look past the first quote. Add a gravel board and capping to a panel fence — which you should — and part of the saving goes. Count the first replacement panel or two and more of it goes. Put the fence on an exposed boundary and the saving is gone by the second winter.
So when are panels the right call? Honestly: a sheltered garden, a tight budget, a fence that only needs to look tidy for a few years — a rental, a house you are selling, a boundary that a new hedge will replace. In those cases we will fit panels and tell you so. Our wooden fencing and panels page covers the panel options. If the boundary is exposed, long, or the last fence you want to put up there, it is closeboard, and if you never want to treat it again it is worth a look at composite fencing, which costs more still but ends the maintenance conversation entirely.
Storm Season: What Actually Fails First
The named storms that come through Shropshire between November and February take fences in a predictable order. Having repaired a lot of them, this is the sequence we see.
- First: lap panels on timber posts, no gravel board. The panel lifts, the timber post has rotted at ground level, and the whole bay goes. Common on estate boundaries that were fenced when the houses were built and never touched since.
- Second: lap panels on concrete posts. The posts stand; the panels blow out of the slots or split along the staples. The garden is full of panel.
- Third: closeboard on timber posts without a gravel board. The boards are fine. The posts have rotted at the ground and the fence leans. This is usually a post-by-post repair, not a rebuild.
- Last, and rarely: closeboard on concrete posts with gravel boards. A handful of boards, occasionally a capping rail. Two hours with a hammer.
We repair storm-damaged closeboard across Shrewsbury and Telford right through the winter, including fences we did not put up. If you are going into the autumn with a boundary you are not sure about, our guide to autumn and winter maintenance has a section on checking fence posts before the weather turns, and the garden fencing guide covers the wider choice of styles.
Common Questions
Is it closeboard or close board?
Same fence. The trade says closeboard; merchants and older websites sometimes write close board or close-board, and you will also hear it called feather edge or featheredge after the tapered boards it is built from. Whatever you call it, it is vertical overlapping boards nailed to horizontal rails and built on site — not a factory panel.
Which lasts longer in Shropshire, closeboard or lap panels?
Closeboard, and it is not close. On concrete posts with a gravel board a closeboard fence is normally good for 20 years and often 25. Lap panels on the same posts typically need replacing from around year 8 to 12, and on an exposed plot they can fail in a single winter.
Can a lap panel fence be repaired after a storm?
Only by replacing the whole panel. Once a lap panel has split or blown out of its slot there is nothing to repair; the panel comes out and a new one goes in, and matching the weathered colour of the rest is luck. A closeboard fence is repaired board by board, so a storm that takes six boards costs six boards.
Are lap panels ever the right choice?
Yes. In a sheltered town garden with no wind exposure, where the budget is tight or the fence only needs to last a few years, panels are a perfectly reasonable choice and we fit plenty of them. The mistake is putting panels on an exposed boundary and expecting them to survive.
Want It Built, Not Bought In?
If the boundary is exposed, long, or simply one you want to put up once and forget about, have a look at our closeboard fencing page for how we build it, then get in touch for a site visit. We measure the run, check the ground, and tell you straight whether it is concrete posts or timber, capped or not, closeboard or panels — and we will say panels if that is honestly the right answer for your garden.
Shrewsbury, Telford, Oswestry, Market Drayton, Whitchurch, Wem and all of Shropshire. The visit is free and the advice comes from 29 years of putting fences up in this weather.
The field-fence version of this story: How the Fence Learned to Stand.
Want It Built, Not Bought In?
Free site visit across Shrewsbury, Telford and all of Shropshire. Concrete or timber, capped or not, repair or rebuild — we tell you straight.
Closeboard Fencing