This is a story we have watched happen on a hundred holdings between Whitchurch and Much Wenlock. A simple but timeless story, with some name changes, and everything else kept exactly as it was. If you have a fence that leans, you may recognise it.
There was once a fence on the heavy clay above Hodnet, and it was not a happy fence.
It ran three hundred metres along the top of a field that sloped down to a brook, and it had been put up in a hurry one dry week in August by a man who had a lot of other things to do that week. He wasn't a bad man and it wasn't a bad fence. It was just a fence that had never been taught to stand.
This is the story of how it learned.
How the Fence Was Put Up in a Hurry
You must understand, the way the Man with the Other Things to Do saw it. A fence was posts and wire and the sooner they were in the ground the better.
So the posts went into the ground. Not very deep, because the clay was hard in August and the auger was borrowed and had to go back by Thursday. The wire went on next, and it was pulled as tight as two arms could pull it and stapled where it sat, which felt tight enough at the time. Then a roll of netting was unrolled along the lot, and by the end of the week there was a fence where there had not been a fence before. At the end, a Man stood at the top of the field with his hands on his hips and was pleased.
The corner posts had no struts. The strainers, if you could call them strainers, were the same posts as all the others, only at the ends. Nobody had walked the run first to see where the ground dipped, so the netting bellied over the low place by the brook like a sail with no wind in it.
But it was August, and the ground was hard, plus it stood.
How the Wind Came Off the Long Mynd
Then October came, as it does, and after October the rain. After the rain was the wind, which in that part of Shropshire comes down off the Long Mynd with nothing to slow it for twenty miles.
The clay, which had been hard as a road in August, went soft. Not muddy exactly, but soft. The way it does, so that anything standing in it could be persuaded to lean. And the wire, which was pulling on the corner posts all day and all night, every hour of every day, began to persuade them.
The corner post at the brook end leaned first. Only an inch. Nobody noticed. But an inch at the corner is a hand's width in the middle, and by Christmas the top wire had the gentle droop of a washing line, and by February the netting was resting its chin on the grass.
The Man with the Other Things to Do looked at it from the kitchen window and thought: I'll sort that in the spring.
How the Ewes Learned the Lane
Now, a ewe does not read the calendar. But a ewe knows a slack fence when she leans on one.
In May, with the grass coming and the lambs at foot, the first ewe found the low place by the brook, put her shoulder to the netting and walked through it as if it were a bead curtain. The rest of the flock, being sheep, followed on the grounds that she seemed to know something.
The Man spent a Tuesday morning that he did not have on the lane between Hodnet and Marchamley with a bucket of nuts and a dog that had not been told the plan. When he had got them back and propped the fence with a pallet and a length of baler twine, he did what people in that situation always do.
He rang someone.
How the Boundary Was Walked
We came on the Thursday. And here is the part of the story that matters, because it is the part most people skip.
We did not price the fence from the kitchen window. We walked it. All three hundred metres, from the leaning corner by the brook, up the slope, along the top and back down to the lane. We pushed on every post. We dug a hole at the worst place to see what the ground was doing under the surface.
And this is what we found, which is what we nearly always find: sixty metres of that fence had gone. The posts at the brook end were rotting at ground level and the corner had leaned so far there was nothing left to tension against. But the other two hundred and forty metres were sound. Slack, yes. Tired, yes. But the posts were good and the netting was good, and all that run wanted was proper strainers at each end and the wire pulled up again.
So that is what we priced. Sixty metres refenced, two hundred and forty re-tensioned. Not three hundred metres of new fence, which is what a quote from the kitchen window would have said.
The Man, who had been braced for a number twice the size, said something we have heard a lot in twenty-nine years, which was: “Nobody's ever walked it before.”
How the Strainer Went In
If you take one thing from this story, take this: the strainer post is the fence. Everything else, the netting, the line wires, the little posts in between, hangs off it. It is the anchor the whole run pulls against. Get the strainer right and the fence stays tight for years. Get it wrong and nothing you do afterwards matters.
So the strainers went in first. Big posts, deep, at each corner and at every change of direction, and one more in the middle of the long top run because a long straight needs somewhere to pull from. Each one was strutted, a second timber braced back from it against the pull of the wire, so that when the tension came on, the post had something behind it. That is what the fence in August never had.
Then the intermediates, driven where the ground allowed, so that the clay was packed tight around them all the way down instead of loose fill in a dug hole. Then the line wires, strained between the strainers with a proper tensioning tool until they sang, and stapled loosely so they could move with the weather rather than fight it. Then netting sized for what was in the field, with the small mesh at the bottom for the lambs and a top wire above for the ewes with ambition.
The old wire came out of the hedge bottom where it had been left, and went away with us.
It took three days. When we drove off, the fence was tight enough to bounce a coin on, and it was still only September.
How the Fence Learned to Stand
Then October came, as it does, and after October the rain, and after the rain the wind off the Long Mynd.
The clay went soft. The wire pulled on the corner posts all day and all night, every hour of every day. And the corner posts, strutted and deep, pushed back.
The top wire stayed a top wire. The netting stayed off the grass. By February, when the whole county was slack and leaning and propped with pallets, that fence on the clay above Hodnet stood exactly where we had left it, and the Man with the Other Things to Do looked at it from the kitchen window and, for the first time, did not think about it at all.
Which is the whole point of a fence. A good one is a thing you stop noticing.
What the Story Is Really About
We could have told you this as a list. Strainers first. Walk the boundary. Price by the section. Tension the wire properly. Do it in the autumn while the ground takes a post cleanly and the stock are in. We have written that list, in fact, and it is a good list: our stock fencing guide for Shropshire smallholdings has the netting types, the post spacing and what it costs.
But the list does not tell you why the fence on the clay failed, and the story does. It failed because it was put up in a hurry by someone who had never been shown the difference between a post at the end of a fence and a strainer. That is not a criticism of the Man. Most fences in Shropshire were put up that way. It is why we get the phone calls.
And it is not only stock fencing. The same story plays out on the garden side of the house, where a run of lap panels on timber posts goes up in a weekend and comes down in the first proper gale. A closeboard fence built on site, board by board on concrete posts with a gravel board underneath, is the domestic version of the strutted strainer. It costs a little more on the day, and it is still standing when the panels next door are in the neighbour's pond. We have written that one up too: closeboard versus lap panels in Shropshire weather.
Both stories end the same way. The fence you pay for once is the one that was built to stand.
The Season Is Now
Here is the thing about fencing in Shropshire that nobody tells you until you have chased sheep down a lane: autumn is the window.
From now until late winter, the ground takes a post cleanly, the stock are in or on winter grazing, and the diary has room. A fence that goes up in October settles, tightens and is tested by the worst of the weather before the grass comes and the animals go back out. A fence that fails in May, with stock in the field and every fencing contractor in the county already booked, costs you the stock, not just the fence.
The same clock runs for the garden. The storms that take lap panels down arrive between now and March. If a run is already leaning, it will not make it.
So if you have a fence that has been I'll sort that in the spring for longer than you would like to admit, this is the moment. We walk the whole boundary, we tell you plainly which runs need refencing and which just want re-tensioning, and we price it by the section. Anywhere in Shropshire, from the TF9 clay around Market Drayton and Loggerheads to the sandy ground up towards Whitchurch and Wem, and down to Much Wenlock and the Edge. If the farm track along the boundary has gone as well, we will look at that on the same visit. One team, one price, one lot of mud.
Three Questions People Ask Us in October
Is it too late in the year to put up a fence?
No. Autumn and winter are when we do most of our stock fencing. The ground is soft enough to drive a post and firm enough to hold it, the fields are empty, and the fence is tight and settled before turnout. The only thing that stops us is standing water on the run, and if that is the problem, the fence is not the first job.
My fence is slack but the posts look fine. Do I need a new one?
Probably not. If the strainers at the corners are sound and upright, a slack run can nearly always be re-tensioned and a few intermediates replaced for a fraction of the cost of refencing. If the corners have leaned or rotted, that section has to come out because there is nothing left to tension against. The only way to know is to walk it, which is what the free visit is for.
Can you do the garden fence and the field fence in one go?
Yes, and people often do. The agricultural and stock fencing around the paddock and a closeboard run on the garden side of the house are different jobs done by the same team, and it is usually cheaper to have us on site once than twice.
Get the boundary walked before winter
Free visit anywhere in Shropshire. Which runs need refencing, which just want re-tensioning, priced by the section. Call 01743 816170 or ask for a quote.
Don't Leave It Until Spring
Free boundary walk anywhere in Shropshire. Field fence or garden fence, we tell you which runs need replacing and which just want re-tensioning, and price it by the section.
Stock & Agricultural Fencing Closeboard Fencing