We have watched this story play out on closes and cul-de-sacs from Wellington to Wem for twenty-nine years. The names are changed and the street is nobody's in particular. The two driveways, we are sorry to say, are real.
There were once two driveways on the same close in Wellington, and they were laid in the same spring, three doors apart, by two different companies.
On the day they were finished you could not have told them apart. Same blocks, near enough. Same colour. Same Saturday-morning neighbours standing at the end of them saying, well, that's smart. By the third winter you could tell them apart from the end of the road, and this is the story of why.
How the First Driveway Was Bought
The Man at number eleven had three quotes, which is the right number, and he took the cheapest, which is sometimes the right answer and was not this time.
The cheapest quote was a figure. Just a figure, on the back of a card, with a mobile number and a first name. It did not say how deep they would dig. It did not say what would go in the hole before the blocks went on top. It did not say what would happen to the rain, or who would be doing the work, or what would happen if something went wrong in a year's time. It said a number, and the number was a good one, and the Man at number eleven shook a hand on it.
They came on a Monday in a van with no name on it. They were gone by the Wednesday, and the drive looked lovely.
What the Man did not see, because it was under the blocks by Tuesday lunchtime, was this. They had taken off the old surface and about a hand's depth of what was underneath it. Into that went a thin spread of something that was sold to them as sub-base and was really crushed-up rubble from somebody else's job. It was not compacted, because they had not brought anything to compact it with. On top of that went sand, and on top of the sand went the blocks, and around the edge went nothing at all, because edging restraints are a day's work and the number on the card had not allowed for a day's work.
It was paid in cash, in full, on the Wednesday afternoon. The card with the number on it went in the kitchen drawer.
How the Second Driveway Was Bought
The Woman at number seventeen also had three quotes, and she also wanted to spend as little as she reasonably could, because nobody enjoys spending money on the bit of their house they drive over.
But she was the sort of person who reads the small print on a tin of paint, and so when the three companies came round she asked each of them the same questions, and she wrote the answers down.
How deep will you dig? What goes in the hole? How is it compacted? Where does the water go when it rains? What holds the edges in? Who actually does the work, you or someone you've phoned? Can I see your insurance? What do I get in writing when you have finished? And, which is the one most people forget, can you give me the address of a drive you laid five years ago, so I can go and stand on it?
One of the three could not really answer any of that, and got a bit short with her for asking. One answered most of it. One answered all of it, in writing, on a quotation that ran to two pages and had the depth of excavation, the sub-base material and thickness, the laying course, the blocks, the edging, the drainage and the guarantee all set out, with a company name and a landline and an address you could drive to.
It was not the cheapest. It was not the dearest either. She took it.
They came on a Monday too. They were there most of the week. There was a digger, and a skip, and a great deal of hardcore going in before anything went on top, and on the Tuesday a man spent the whole day on his knees setting kerbs in concrete around the edge, which looked like nothing at all when he had finished because that is what kerbs are supposed to look like. The blocks went down on the Thursday. She paid a deposit at the start and the balance when it was done, and both went through the bank with the company's name on the statement.
How the Winter Came, As It Does
The first winter was kind, and both drives came through it.
The second winter was wet, as Shropshire winters mostly are, and in February the Man at number eleven noticed that there was a puddle by the garage door that had not been there before, and that the blocks either side of it rocked under his foot like loose teeth. By the end of the third winter the two lines where the car's wheels sat had sunk the thickness of a finger, the sand had washed out of the joints and the weeds had moved in, and along the left-hand edge, where nothing had been holding anything in, the blocks had started to lean outward into the lawn like a row of books with the bookend gone.
He got the card out of the kitchen drawer. The number went to a voicemail that was full.
Three doors up, the Woman at number seventeen had not thought about her driveway once in three years, which is, if you remember the story about the fence, the whole point. The water went where it had been told to go. The edges stayed where they had been put. The blocks sat on a base that had been built to carry a car for a very long time, and so they carried one.
What the Story Is Really About
Here is the uncomfortable part. On the Wednesday afternoon of that first spring, both driveways looked the same. A driveway is the one job on a house where almost everything that matters is buried by lunchtime on the second day. You cannot inspect the sub-base once the blocks are on it. You cannot see whether the edges are haunched in concrete or sitting in soil. The finish tells you almost nothing about the build.
So you cannot choose a paving company by looking at the finished job. You have to choose them by what they are prepared to tell you, and put in writing, before they start. Which is why the Woman at number seventeen's list of questions is the most useful thing in this story, and we have written it out properly below.
The Nine Questions to Ask Any Paving Company
Ask all nine. Ask them of everybody who quotes, including us. A good company will be pleased you asked; a poor one will get short with you, and that tells you what you need to know.
- How deep will you dig, and what goes in the hole?For a domestic driveway taking cars, expect a compacted sub-base of properly graded MOT Type 1 at least 150mm deep, more on the heavy clay you get around Market Drayton and Loggerheads. If the answer is vague, or "it depends what we find" with no figure attached, that is your answer.
- How is the sub-base compacted?In layers, with a plate compactor or roller, not by driving the van over it. A sub-base that is not compacted will settle under the first winter's rain, and the blocks will go down with it.
- Where does the rainwater go?If you are surfacing more than five square metres of front garden with an impermeable material and it drains to the road, you need planning permission; a permeable surface or a drive that drains to a border or soakaway does not. Any company working in Shropshire should know this and should say so unprompted. Our planning permission guide has the detail, and permeable paving is usually the simplest way round it.
- What holds the edges in?Block paving and gravel both need an edge restraint, kerbs or edging blocks set in concrete, along every side that is not a wall. Without it the surface spreads outward over the first few years, exactly as it did at number eleven.
- Is all of that written on the quote?A real quotation itemises the excavation depth, the sub-base material and thickness, the laying course, the surface, the edging, the drainage and the price, with a company name, an address and a landline on it. A number on a card is not a quotation. It is an opening offer.
- Who will actually do the work?Ask whether the people who quote are the people who turn up. Plenty of firms sell the job and subcontract the labour to whoever is free that week, and the quality follows the subcontractor, not the salesman. We do not use subcontractors, and we will introduce you to the team at the survey.
- Can I see your public liability insurance?Not "are you insured", which everyone says yes to. Ask to see the certificate. A company that is insured will have it on the van or will email it the same day.
- What guarantee do I get, and is it in writing?There should be two: the manufacturer's product warranty on the blocks, resin or aggregate, and the company's own written workmanship guarantee. Verbal guarantees are worth exactly what the Man at number eleven found his to be worth.
- Can I go and stand on one you laid five years ago?Any company that has been trading a while will have drives it is proud of all over the county and will happily give you a couple of addresses to drive past. Google reviews help too; read the recent ones and the three-star ones, not just the five-star ones.
The red flags, in case you are short of time
- A van with no name, a mobile number and no address you could visit.
- "We've got some tarmac left over from a job down the road." Nobody reputable has tarmac left over.
- A price with no specification under it.
- Pressure to decide today, and a discount for deciding today.
- Cash in full before the job starts, or on the day it finishes.
Is the Cheapest Quote Always the Wrong One?
No, and we would be lying if we said otherwise. Sometimes the cheapest quote is from a good local firm with a quiet fortnight and a yard full of material it wants to use. The question is not whether a quote is cheap. The question is whether you can see why it is cheap on the specification. If three companies have quoted the same depth, the same sub-base, the same edging and the same guarantee, and one is a few hundred pounds less, that is competition and you should enjoy it. If one is a third of the price and has not written down what you are getting for it, the saving is coming out of the hole in the ground, and you will meet it again in the third winter.
Our own driveway cost guide sets out what moves the price up and down, so you can tell a genuine saving from a missing sub-base.
How We Quote, So You Can Hold Us to It
We have been laying block paving, tarmac, resin bound and gravel across Shropshire since 1997, from our office at 8 Shoplatch in Shrewsbury, and the quotation you get from us answers all nine questions before you have asked them. Free site survey. A written quote with the depths and materials on it. Our own employed team, no subcontractors. Public liability certificate on request. A written workmanship guarantee on top of the manufacturer's warranty, up to 15 years on approved materials from Tobermore, Daltex and Polybound. And a Google rating of 4.9 from more than 120 reviews, which you are welcome to read before you ring.
Ask us the nine questions. We will be pleased you did. And if you are three doors from a drive that is starting to rock under your feet, we can come and look at that too.
Questions People Ask Us About Choosing a Driveway Company
How many quotes should I get for a new driveway?
Three is the right number. Fewer and you have nothing to compare; more and you are just collecting cards. Make sure all three are quoting the same specification, or you are comparing a sub-base with a hole.
Does a paving company need to be licensed or registered in the UK?
No. There is no licence for laying driveways in the UK, which is exactly why insurance, a written guarantee and a traceable address matter so much. Manufacturer accreditations, such as Tobermore registered installer status, are voluntary and mean the installer has been trained and assessed by the manufacturer, so they are worth asking about.
What should be on a driveway quote?
Excavation depth, sub-base material and compacted thickness, laying course, the surface material and its thickness, edge restraints, drainage or permeability, the price, payment terms, the guarantee, and the company's full name, address and landline. If any of those are missing, ask for them before you sign anything.
Should I pay for a driveway in cash?
Pay a deposit and the balance on completion, by bank transfer or card, to a company whose name is on the statement. Paying cash in full up front removes every lever you have if something goes wrong, and it is the clearest red flag in the trade.
Get a quotation you can hold us to
Free survey anywhere in Shropshire. Depths, materials and guarantee in writing, before a spade goes in. Call 01743 816170 or ask for a written quote.
The companion pieces: why a local company still matters, and which surface suits your house once you have chosen who will lay it.
Ask Us the Nine Questions
Free site survey across Shrewsbury, Telford and all of Shropshire. Every answer in writing on the quote, before a spade goes in the ground.
Get a Written Quote 01743 816170